Our Story
The History and Heart
of St. Peter Lutheran Church
How It All Started
1967 – The First Worship Service
The first worship service of St. Peter Evangelical Lutheran Church was held on September 17, 1967, at the Women’s Club of Fort Myers Beach on Sterling Street. There were 37 worshipers in attendance—humble beginnings for what would become a faithful and enduring congregation.
1968 – Organizing the Congregation
In the spring of 1968, a 500’ x 250’ tract of land was purchased at 3751 Estero Boulevard for $54,000. Later that year, on November 22, an Altar Guild was formed, and in September the Planning Board met to guide the next steps for the church.
On December 1, 1968—the first Sunday in Advent—St. Peter Lutheran Church was officially organized with 69 adults and 13 children. The first Church Council was installed during worship, followed by a joyful fellowship dinner with blessings from other Beach churches. Just weeks later, on December 22, the choir debuted their new robes.
1976 – Building St. Peter Park
In 1976, members began clearing land for what would become St. Peter Park. The park was dedicated on December 18, 1976, providing a peaceful space for fellowship, recreation, and reflection.
1978 – Tenth Anniversary
On December 3, 1978, St. Peter celebrated its 10th anniversary. The church gave thanks for a decade of growth and service, supported by many associate members who wintered on Fort Myers Beach. Their ongoing friendship and generosity enriched the life of the congregation. “All honor and glory to God, who has so richly blessed us.”
1985 – Mortgage Burning Celebration
Amid great rejoicing, the congregation burned the sanctuary mortgage on March 24, 1985—exactly fifteen years after the first service was held in the church building. This milestone marked both financial freedom and the deep commitment of members who had given generously of their time, labor, and love.
2018 – 50th Anniversary Celebration
On December 2, 2018, St. Peter Lutheran Church celebrated 50 years of ministry. Bishop Pedro Suarez presided at worship and joined in a joyous celebration in Lau Fellowship Hall—a moment of gratitude for five decades of faith, love, and service.
2022 – Hurricane Ian
On September 28, 2022, Hurricane Ian, a Category 5 storm, struck Fort Myers Beach. The devastation was immense—Lau Hall was lost, and the main sanctuary sustained severe damage. Through prayer, perseverance, and faith, the congregation continued to worship under a tent in the parking lot, finding strength in God’s promise of renewal.
Today – Faith Endures
On Palm Sunday, April 13, 2025, after more than two and a half years, the congregation processed from the tent back into the sanctuary. It was a deeply emotional and sacred moment. There was not a dry eye in the house!
Expanding the Vision
The first piling was driven on November 18, 1991. Only eight months later, July 6, 1992, the congregation processed from the old sanctuary to the new and the first worship service was held. On December 6, 1992, the new sanctuary was dedicated by the Reverend Sue Gamelin, Associate to the Reverend Lavern Franzen, Bishop, Florida-Bahamas Synod of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America.
St. Peter Evangelical Lutheran Church celebrated its 25th anniversary on December 5, 1993, with Bishop Lavern Franzen officiating. Following the service, Bishop Franzen joined the congregation for dinner in the fellowship hall (the old sanctuary), where he was the guest speaker.
Through the years, the ministry of St. Peter Evangelical Lutheran Church has grown to keep pace with the needs of the church, its members and the community. Among its ministries are the Chancel Choir, Sunday School for children and adults, mid-week Lenten Services, the Altar Guild, the Women of the ELCA, the Men’s Club, the Monday Morning Work Crew, and participation in Beach Meals, community worship services and various synod projects.
Through his spirituality, dedication, perseverance, guidance and patient love, Pastor Lau e St. Peter enabled Evangelical Lutheran Church and each member of the congregation to grow personally and spiritually. During Pastor Lau’s last worship service on June 25, 1995 the mortgage on the new sanctuary was burned.
Pastor Lau was given a retirement dinner on June 25, 1995, as a token of appreciation of the congregation of St. Peter Lutheran Church for his 26 years of service as called pastor. He retired on July 31, 1995. Pastor William B. Renn served as interim pastor, assisted by the Rev. George C. Serbe, Jr. The Reverend C. Thomas Snapp was called to serve as pastor and began his ministry here on May 8, 1996. At that time Pastor Renn agreed to be Assistant to the Pastor and Pastor Serbe retired (again).On February 15, 1998, St. Peter held a dedication for the Lau Fellowship Hall.
On November 15, 2010, Pastor Lorrie Davison was installed. Pastor Lorrie served until her retirement in January 2018. Interim Pastor Charles “Rusty” May served the congregation until November 2019.